This is the #1 Mistake People Make with Portfolio Withdrawals - Root Financial

Having the right withdrawal strategy is crucial to ensure a comfortable and financially secure retirement. While the 4% rule is a popular approach, it’s important to understand the common mistake that can cost retirees dearly. Today we’ll explore this mistake and discuss a better strategy to prevent it.

The 4% rule suggests that if you have a portfolio consisting of 50% US stocks and 50% intermediate-term US bonds, you can withdraw 4% of your portfolio value in the initial years of retirement, assuming you want your money to last for at least 30 years. While this rule can be a good starting point, it overlooks a critical factor: the reality of staggered income and expenses in retirement.

Staggered Income and Expenses

During retirement, it’s common to have staggered income sources. For example, you or your spouse may delay claiming Social Security benefits until a later age. This means that in the early years of retirement, you’ll have a greater need for income from your portfolio. As you start receiving Social Security benefits, the need for withdrawals from your portfolio decreases. This creates a fluctuating income stream throughout retirement.

Similarly, your expenses in retirement may not remain constant. For instance, you may have a mortgage that will be paid off after a few years, resulting in a reduction in living expenses. Additionally, travel expenses or other discretionary costs may vary over time. As a result, your retirement budget may change at different stages.

Comprehensive Approach

To account for these factors, it’s crucial to take a more comprehensive approach to withdrawal strategies. Instead of relying solely on a fixed withdrawal rate, it’s important to consider the unique circumstances of your retirement plan. Here’s an alternative approach to help you optimize your withdrawal strategy:

  1. Break down your portfolio: Instead of viewing your portfolio as one entity, divide it into different tranches that correspond to the different phases of retirement. Each tranche will support specific income and expense needs during different periods.
  2. Determine your initial expense tranche: Calculate the amount of money you’ll need to cover your higher expenses in the early years of retirement. This could include mortgage payments, travel expenses, or any other significant costs. Consider setting aside a portion of your portfolio, such as cash or conservative investments, to cover these expenses for the first few years, regardless of market fluctuations.
  3. Calculate subsequent expense tranches: Determine the reduced expenses for each subsequent phase of retirement. Adjustments can be made for factors like paid-off mortgages or decreased travel expenses. Allocate a portion of your portfolio to support these lower-expense needs during those periods.
  4. Project growth: Estimate the growth potential of the remaining portfolio that will support your needs in the later years of retirement. Consider a more growth-oriented investment strategy for this tranche, as you’ll have a longer time horizon to weather market fluctuations.

By adopting this approach, you can see that your withdrawal strategy becomes more dynamic and tailored to your specific retirement timeline. It allows you to allocate your portfolio effectively, ensuring you have enough funds to cover different income and expense needs throughout retirement.

It’s important to note that this is a simplified example and that individual circumstances may vary. Consulting with a financial advisor can provide personalized guidance based on your unique situation and help you develop a comprehensive retirement plan.

While the 4% rule can provide a starting point, it’s essential to avoid the common mistake of assuming a fixed withdrawal rate throughout retirement. By considering staggered income and expenses and adopting a more dynamic withdrawal strategy, you can ensure your money lasts throughout your retirement years while enjoying your desired lifestyle.

Need help with your retirement?

Work directly with a licensed financial advisor at Root. Book a no-obligation initial call now so we can show you how we’ve helped hundreds of people just like you build a retirement they love.