Avoid This Portfolio Withdrawal Mistake Most People Make in Retirement - Root Financial

I want to talk about something that might challenge the traditional way of thinking about portfolio withdrawals in retirement. If you’ve been basing your retirement income solely on the 4% Rule or similar strategies, you might be missing out on crucial aspects of your financial plan.

The 4% Rule Catch

Picture this: you’ve diligently saved up a substantial nest egg for retirement, and you’re ready to start enjoying the fruits of your labor. According to the 4 percent rule, you can withdraw 4% of your portfolio annually and have a high likelihood of that money lasting for at least 30 years. 

Here’s the catch: real-life spending in retirement rarely follows a linear path. People often have staggered income sources or fluctuating expenses throughout their retirement years, which can significantly impact their withdrawal needs.

If you and your spouse retire at age 65, you may not start collecting Social Security until a few years later. In the meantime, you’ll need to rely more heavily on your portfolio to cover expenses. Then, once Social Security kicks in, your withdrawal requirements may decrease.

Or perhaps your expenses vary over time. Maybe you start retirement with a mortgage and higher travel expenses, but as you pay off the mortgage and scale back on travel, your financial needs decrease accordingly.

Jeffrey and Cindy

To illustrate this point, let’s look at a case study. Jeffrey and Cindy retire with a $750,000 investment portfolio and have planned expenses, including basic living costs, travel funds for the first ten years, and mortgage payments for the first five years. Their Social Security provides additional income.

If we simply apply the 4% Rule without considering their changing expenses, it might suggest they need a larger portfolio to retire comfortably. However, a deeper analysis reveals that their withdrawal needs fluctuate over time. Initially, they require higher withdrawals to cover temporary expenses like travel and mortgage payments. But as these expenses decrease, so does their withdrawal rate.

Withdrawal and Allocation Considerations

It’s essential to look beyond the initial withdrawal rate and consider how your spending patterns evolve throughout retirement. Instead of blindly adhering to a fixed withdrawal strategy, tailor your approach to match your specific financial circumstances.

One way to address this is by segmenting your portfolio to cover different phases of retirement. Allocate a portion of your assets to cover higher early expenses, such as travel or paying off debts, while investing the rest for long-term growth to sustain you in later years.

By taking a more nuanced approach to retirement withdrawals, you can better align your financial plan with your actual needs and enjoy a more fulfilling retirement without unnecessary sacrifices or financial worries.

While the 4% Rule and similar guidelines provide valuable insights, they’re not one-size-fits-all solutions. Real-life retirement spending is dynamic, and your withdrawal strategy should reflect that. It’s important to take the time to understand your evolving financial needs and adjust your portfolio accordingly for a more secure and enjoyable retirement journey.

Need help with your retirement?

Work directly with a licensed financial advisor at Root. Book a no-obligation initial call now so we can show you how we’ve helped hundreds of people just like you build a retirement they love.